Captain America and the American Dream
Every day in my classroom, I hold a Lunch Bunch were 9th and 10th grade students come to my class, eat their lunch, talk with their friends, and watch superhero TV shows and movies I play using my projector. I do not teach all the students who attend my lunch bunch. In fact, I only have about 1/3 of them assigned to my daily class schedule, but my classroom has become a needed sanctuary for the nerdy and geeky rather than being forced into the loud and crowded cafeteria. Throughout the year we build relationships with one another as we have conversations about good and bad Marvel movies, what has happened in the latest comic book issues I have in my room, or I tutor them on how to write a PEAL paragraph for their literary analysis essay. Most days, the seats are packed and it is like I am teaching an extra class, but I love it and so do my students.
This Black History Month, we watched Black Panther and the entire “Falcon and Winter Soldier” series on Disney+. While watching the last few scenes of the series with my students, Sam Wilson makes a short, but impactful speech to Isaiah Bradley after the forgotten Captain America says, “The fight you takin on, not gonna be easy, Sam.” Isaiah is talking about being the new Captain America who is also black and not Steve Rogers. Sam tells Isaiah, “Yeah, I might fail. Shit, I might die. But, we built this country. Bled for it. I’m not gonna let anybody tell me I can’t fight for it. Not after what everybody before me went through. Including you.” This speech, and the entire Captain America: Brave New World film helped remind what true integrity looks like.
In his book Integrity, Stephen Carter defines integrity as having 3 steps of moral reflection:
1. discerning what is right and what is wrong
2. acting on what you have discerned, even at personal cost, and
3. saying openly that you are acting on your understanding of right and wrong
Although Carter’s definition seems to be clear enough, understanding how to distinguish integrity from those who do not possess it can sometimes seem impossible in a society where we determine a person’s worth by their salary, number of likes on a social media post, or followers on their platform. However, fictional superhero characters like Sam provide me and others with a model that may be missing in reality.
On this last day of Black History Month, Sam has helped me discern the difference between what is right, what is easy, and what it means to blindly follow the rules. Sometimes, the laws are corrupt because the people who created them were flawed. Sometimes, this means choosing to fight a battle that will get you into, “Good trouble,” as the late John Lewis called it. This also means acting on it, even at the risk of personal cost whether it be financially or socially. It means taking a risk to battle even if the world tells you you’re wrong. To tell them what you are doing to inspire others. Many times, this battle will be fought alone and in secret, but it will create a more just world.
It’s because of fictional superheroes like Sam Wilson (Captain America), Isaiah Bradley (Captain America), John Stewart (Green Lantern), Calvin Ellis (Superman of Earth-23), Jefferson Pierce (Black Lightning), and countless others that I continue to write and speak for survivors when the world tells me to remain silent. To do what is easy rather than what is right. Unfortunately, this is the only way I know to continue being a good man, and a good person in a world where my only superpower is believing that we can be better.
Be Better
Picture the Batman. Hold the image in your mind. What do you see? Maybe a black cowl with white eyes, rippling abs, bulging biceps, and a cape the color of night capable of hiding the blur of fists and kicks as they assault the criminals of Gotham. You may see a man on his own with his own agenda as he battles the war on crime with nothing but his fists, fancy car, and bottomless bank account of funding any and all of his latest gadgets.
What makes Batman #150 “Be Better” (2024) stand out among other Batman comics is the fact that it is none of these things. In fact, the comic hardly includes Batman at all. Instead, the story follows the thoughts and actions of thug-for-hire, Teddy.
Teddy has made his living working for the criminal underbelly most of his adult life. He has been a henchman for B level villains throughout Gotham such as Ventriloquist and Firefly. He has been an absent deadbeat father and an abusive ungrateful partner. He views himself as the victim who has always been given the short end of the stick. Teddy perpetuates a lie to himself and his wife, Kim as he storms out of the apartment after coming home drunk the night prior, “I get it, Kim. I’m a loser. You’ve been #@$%& clear about that for years. All I’ve ever done is try to provide for this family.”
Teddy is a lowlife who only cares for himself and making a quick buck. However, Teddy has a secret he believes will be the game changer needed to turn his life around. He has discovered the secret identity of Batman and he believes he can cash in to live on easy street.
First, Teddy tries to sell the information to the villain, Two-Face, but the duplicitous villain already knows the Caped Crusader’s alter ego and he could care less. Next, Teddy attempts to see the information to the Cobblepot Twins (the Penguin’s children), but the transaction falls through. Finally, he ends up with a group of low-level henchmen like himself who plan on using Teddy as collateral against Batman if he attempts to stop them from robbing a bank. Of course, Batman being Batman, he stops the crime before it can ever occur, knocks Teddy out and leaves him to wake up alone in the dorm room of his son who attends Gotham University.
The adolescent explains how he attempted to follow in the footsteps of his father as a henchman for the villain, Scarecrow. The boy explains how he looked up to his father, taking Teddy’s side over the side of his mother, and viewing the busted knuckles and hand gun of his father as a sign of pride. However, when Batman saved the boy from being poisoned by Scarecrow’s fear toxin, he began to see things differently. Batman listens to the youth and agrees to pay for his education at Gotham University on one condition: be better.
When Teddy is told he is not what a man is supposed to be, Teddy defends himself by stating, “I am! I hustled! I put food on your table! And this is how you treat me?! I did it for you! Risked my life! For you and your mother!” The son rebuttals and tells Teddy, “You hurt people, helped monsters, because you wanted to. Because you were too scared to enter the real world and have actual responsibilities. And you were addicted to the idea of easy money.”
Teddy takes his son’s words to heart. He leaves the dorm room and meets Bruce Wayne on the steps of the university with tears in his eyes. Bruce Wayne agrees to pay for Teddy to begin a new life in Metropolis, off the radar of those seeking to cash in on the knowledge he possessed. The only thing Bruce asks is that Teddy attempts to be better.
So often, as men we view ourselves as victims without options who are only capable of living a life of others rather than ourselves. No, we aren’t henchmen for Two-Face and the Penguin, but we work a 9 to 5 in an office that can be soul crushing. The people we care for look up to us and notice our sacrifice, but still we believe we deserve more. So, we become Teddy. We push those who love us away and only dole out moments of affection we believe capable of affording. Soon, we become the villain as we seek easy money in the form of get-rich-quick schemes and gambling. We view ourselves as screw ups rather than through the eyes of those who see us as heroes. These people don’t want the next big score that will put them on easy street. Instead, they desire a father and husband who is present and putting in the work day-after-day to be better. Not be perfect, but to be better than the man who woke up the previous morning. Some days we will fall short, but each time we try to show people we love what it means to be a good man.